217 Butler Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON L0S 1J0

For Sale 5 days on Market MLS® X13118556
Asking Price
$4,750,000
Oracle AI
Full Report →
Overview
Active
Situated in one of Niagara-on-the-Lake's most admired settings, this remarkable property offers a rare combination of scale, character, privacy, and location. Set on nearly an acre at the prominent corner of Queen and Butler, the home captures beautiful outlooks across the golf course (the oldest golf course in Ontario, and one of the oldest in Canada) toward Lake Ontario, all within steps of the shops, restaurants, and charm of Queen Street. The classic white clapboard residence offers more than 5,500 square feet above grade and has been thoughtfully restored, renovated, and expanded to create a warm and inviting home with generous principal spaces. Gas and wood-burning fireplaces add character throughout, while multiple walkouts create an effortless connection to the gardens and outdoor living areas. The property also includes a separate annex, offering excellent flexibility for guests, family, or private work space, with a bedroom, living and dining area, kitchen, and den or second bedroom. The annex was originally converted from a two-car garage, and it could be converted back. Outdoors, the grounds feel like a private retreat. Mature trees, English-style gardens, flagstone patios, a koi pond with bubbler fountain, and a large inground pool create a series of beautiful spaces for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying the sun throughout the day. A special offering in one of Niagara's most desirable locations, this property would be equally well suited as an elegant year-round residence or as a memorable getaway for gathering with family and friends. Enjoy all that the Niagara Region has to offer; the Shaw Festival, golf, biking, boating, wineries, and more!
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
6.0
Area
5,000 sqft
Lot Size
0.6 acres
Type
Detached

Property Details

Year BuiltNot Disclosed
CityNiagara-on-the-Lake
Postal CodeL0S1J0
Lot Dimensions138.00 × 200.00 ft
Parking5 spaces

Interior Features

Heat: Forced Air
Heat Source: Gas
Cooling: Central Air
Style: 2-Storey

Exterior & Land

Sewer: Sewer
Construction: Wood
Roof: Asphalt Shingle

Utilities & Services

Heat SourceGas
SewerSewer

Financial Information

List Price$4,750,000
Annual Taxes$28,668 (2025)
Days on Market5
MLS® X13118556 • Listed by ROYAL LEPAGE/J & D DIVISION
217 Butler Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON L0S 1J0
Mon
18
May
Tue
19
May
Wed
20
May
Thu
21
May
Fri
22
May
Sat
23
May
Sun
24
May
Morning8am - 12pm
Afternoon12pm - 5pm
Evening5pm - 9pm
OR
WhatsApp Aman
(416) 845-2151
We're available today until 9 pm.
By submitting this form, you agree your information may be shared to provide the service requested.

Purchase Calculator

$4,750,000.00
$997,500.00

⚙️ Rate

Your mortgage interest rate can either be Fixed for the term or Variable.

4.70%

🧾 Amortization
30 years
Scenario Options
First-time Buyer
Newly Built
Insured Prefer

💸 Rental Income
🏠 Home Expenses
$900.00
100%
$400.00
📉 Taxes
🛠️ Maintenance
⚡ Utilities etc.
Total Monthly Cost ⚙️
0
/month
Principal & interest
Home expenses
Other expenses
Rental income
  • Monthly Mortgage$0.00
  • Home Expenses$0.00
  • Other Expenses$0.00
  • Rental Income$0.00
Mortgage Amount
$0.00
Closing Costs
$0.00

Mortgage Payment$0.00
Net Mortgage$0.00
Interest paid over term$0.00
Balance end of Term$0.00
Effective Amortization30 Years
Property Location
217 Butler Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON L0S 1J0
You May Also Like
Similar Properties in Niagara-on-the-Lake
View all in Niagara-on-the-Lake
Top 5% RE/MAX Ontario
AT
Aman Toor
RE/MAX Realty Specialists Inc.
Rural & Farm Property Expert
Available Now
Meet Your Agent

Aman Toor

Rural & Agricultural Property Specialist — RE/MAX

With over 10 years navigating Ontario's farm and acreage market, Aman brings real data, deep county knowledge, and no-nonsense negotiation to every deal. From 5-acre hobby farms to 500-acre agricultural estates — he's done it all across Dufferin, Simcoe, Grey, Caledon, and beyond.

10+
Years in Rural RE
500+
Properties Sold
98%
Client Satisfaction
🌾 Farm & Agriculture 🏡 Rural Estates 🌲 Vacant Land 🐴 Equestrian 📋 TRREB® Data